top of page
Search

“I would never choose homebirth. So, why should I support it?”

23 hours ago
3 min read

Sally Cusack



You may have noticed that a lot of noise is being made lately about women losing access to homebirth.  This is mainly due to restrictions being placed on registered midwives ability to practice in the home (mainly for insurance reasons) as of 1 January 2027.  


The threat to homebirth midwifery is real.  The list of midwives on the Homebirth Australia website is surprisingly small and a recent survey found that up to 30% of midwives will need to stop practising if the proposed changes go ahead.


Still from the 2018 film These are my Hours"  by Emily Graham and Scott Kirschenbaum
Still from the 2018 film These are my Hours" by Emily Graham and Scott Kirschenbaum

Planned homebirth is admittedly a rare choice among Australian women.  In the latest AIHW Mothers and Babies Report (2026), it was reported that just 0.7% of women gave birth at home with a registered midwife.  


So, if you’re part of the 97% of Australian women who would only ever choose to birth in hospital, why should you have any concern for this issue?


A recent Australian Birth Stories podcast features an interview with home birth midwife and film maker, Jo Hunter, who shares the key insight that the improvements we’ve seen in recent decades to hospital birth is due to home birth.  It is through the relationships built between midwives and families in their homes that we have been able to drag (some aspects of) hospital birthing out of the 1950’s, such as:


  • Fathers are welcomed in hospital birth rooms now, in fact their participation is generally expected. (Non-heterosexual partners are also just as welcome.) A woman’s other children are generally also able to be present during hospital births.  

  • Deep pools for labour and birth are now available in many hospitals around the country, along with sufficiently trained staff to manage water birth.

  • Continuity of midwifery care is available from many hospitals and is recognised as the “gold standard” of care, because it provides the best outcomes for mothers and babies.  (Although we argue, it should in fact be provided as standard care, i.e., provided universally and not kept so out of reach for most women.)

  • Midwifery support for women to birth physiologically, which research shows is what most women want.

  • Providing care that respects a woman’s wishes, which has come to be known as woman-centred care.  This also includes providing the medical interventions that women ask for including planned caesarean sections.

  • And now some hospitals provide homebirth services.


Another point that our Managing Director, Catherine Bell, makes is that we all need to be standing for homebirth because it provides a vital contrast to hospital birth.  Without this contrast, amnesia within the system will quickly set in and these advancements would likely disappear again.  


We can say this with some confidence because the common denominator with all of the improvements listed above is that they lead to no - or very little - “activity”, as defined by the system.  Our hospitals are funded according to the Activity Based Funding system, meaning that hospitals receive funding for each patient and the complexity of their treatment.  This means a hospital will receive the most funding for caesarean sections, as opposed to a woman who just births in a pool with a midwife and her family present.  As a hospital’s viability is attached to its activity, it will tend toward providing more activity, not less.  In spite of all the best of intentions held by staff in the system, and the women who use it, there is no financial incentive for the maternity care system to continue providing woman centred care.


So we protect all birth choices when we speak up for home birth this Saturday 21 November in your local town or city and on Tuesday 24 November in Canberra.  Make sure you register and see you there!


 
 
 

Comments


Contact Us

Your message has been sent - we will reply as soon as possible

ACNC-Registered-Charity-Logo_RGB.png
bottom of page